In An Unusual Move, The EPA Tries To Pull Pesticide From Market

In recent years, a pesticide called flubendiamide has been used on about 14 percent of the nation’s almonds, peppers and watermelons. Now the FDA wants to revoke the chemical’s conditional approval. Scott Olson/Getty Images hide caption

toggle caption Scott Olson/Getty Images

In recent years, a pesticide called flubendiamide has been used on about 14 percent of the nation’s almonds, peppers and watermelons. Now the FDA wants to revoke the chemical’s conditional approval.

Scott Olson/Getty Images

Chances are, you’ve never heard of flubendiamide. It’s not among the most toxic insecticides, and it’s not among the widely used chemicals, either. In recent years, it’s been used on about a quarter of the nation’s tobacco and 14 percent of almonds, peppers and watermelons.

But flubendiamide is now at the center of a public dispute between the Environmental Protection Agency and the company that sells it, Bayer CropScience. That dispute is arousing fear in the pesticide industry — and hope among activists who are pushing for the EPA to regulate pesticides more tightly.

The EPA wants to cancel its approval of this pesticide. The agency says that there is now evidence that this chemical will accumulate in streams and lakes, where it will kill off small, freshwater creatures like snails and crabs that play a crucial role in the entire web of aquatic life.

But the real reason that this decision is attracting so much attention is that flubendiamide is just one of thousands of pesticides that the EPA approved on a “conditional” basis, pending the results of further studies that were required to assure that agency of the chemicals’ safety. The pesticide industry fears — and anti-pesticide groups hope — that many other chemicals, also approved conditionally, soon could face increased EPA scrutiny as well.

“We’re really encouraged that the EPA went for cancellation” of flubendiamide’s approval, rather than a lengthy process known as a “special review,” says Kristin Schafer, policy director at the Pesticide Action Network (PAN).

Conditional approvals allow the EPA to OK a pesticide when the benefits of using it outweigh any apparent risks — such as in a public health emergency. But pesticide critics such as PAN and the Natural Resources Defense Council have criticized the EPA’s heavy reliance on this process. They say it has turned into an easy way for companies to start selling their products without really proving that their products meet legal safety requirements — and that the EPA seldom follows up.

In the case of flubendiamide, the EPA was concerned, from the beginning, about the possibility that the chemical would accumulate in water. The agency has now concluded that this is likely.

The company that sells the pesticide, Bayer CropScience, is refusing, so far, to stop selling the chemical. The company says that the EPA is relying on computer models that overstate the environmental risks, rather than observations of flubendiamide in the real world.

The company is insisting on a hearing before an administrative law judge at the EPA in order to make its case.

Read More at NPR News

Get more stuff like this
in your inbox

Subscribe to our mailing list and get interesting stuff and updates to your email inbox.

Thank you for subscribing.

Something went wrong.

The Salad Trend You Didn’t Know You Needed
Woman Goes from Being Morbidly Obese to Dropping 130 Lbs. and Becoming a Personal Trainer
Mom of 3 Drops 120 Lbs. After Having Her Youngest Child: ‘I Wanted to Get Healthy for My Kids’
Woman Who Lost 185 Lbs. Shows Off Excess Skin: ‘I Wanted People to Realize What Obesity Does’
4 Ideas for Using Herbs You Probably Haven’t Thought Of
Lena Dunham’s Trainer Tracy Anderson Says She Wanted to ‘Feel Better’ and Not Make Her Body ‘Look Different’
Ashley Graham on How Parents Can Teach Their Children Body Positivity by Loving Themselves
Is Collagen Really an Anti-Aging Cure-All?
4 Ideas for Using Herbs You Probably Haven’t Thought Of
The Salad Trend You Didn’t Know You Needed
How To Give Vegan ‘Ice Cream’ That Creamy Taste, Minus The Milk
We ❤ Vegetables—and We Want You To Love Them As Much As We Do!
Spread of combat, cholera wreaks misery, collapse in Yemen
India’s drugmakers need more time to meet international standards: industry group
FDA places clinical hold on Concert Pharma’s hair loss drug
Most U.S. troops kicked out for misconduct had mental illness: study